Skip to main content

Brook Wagman

Contact Us Today: +1 437 228 6291

Has Market Performance Changed Your Portfolio’s Risk?

How disciplined portfolio adjustments help manage investment risk, maintain diversification, and preserve alignment with your long-term financial objectives.

Investment portfolios rarely remain in their original proportions. As financial markets fluctuate, some investments outperform while others grow more slowly or decline. Over time, these differences change the relative weight of individual holdings and asset classes, potentially creating a portfolio that looks substantially different from the one originally designed to support your financial objectives. Without periodic review, these changes can gradually introduce additional risk, reduce diversification, and weaken the relationship between your investment strategy and your actual portfolio.

Year-end offers an important opportunity to evaluate whether your portfolio still reflects your intended investment structure. However, effective rebalancing involves more than selling investments that have performed well and purchasing those that have underperformed. It requires understanding how allocation changes affect risk, how transactions affect your tax position, and whether the adjustments support your long-term financial plan. For Canadian investors, coordinating these considerations before December 31 can help maintain portfolio discipline while managing unnecessary tax exposure.

When Investment Success Changes Your Risk Exposure

A portfolio’s asset allocation reflects the relationship between different investment categories, such as equities, fixed income, and cash. These proportions are typically established based on an investor’s financial objectives, investment horizon, liquidity requirements, and tolerance for market volatility. When market performance changes those proportions, the portfolio’s actual risk characteristics can begin to diverge from the original strategy.

Consider an investor whose portfolio was initially structured with 60% equities and 40% fixed income. Following a sustained period of strong equity performance, the allocation may shift to 70% equities and 30% fixed income. Although the increase in portfolio value may be welcome, the investor is now exposed to a greater proportion of equity market risk than originally intended.

This change can become particularly significant during periods of market volatility. A portfolio that has gradually become more concentrated in equities may experience larger fluctuations than the investor anticipated. Similarly, strong performance from a particular sector or individual security can create unintended concentration, leaving overall portfolio results increasingly dependent on a narrower group of investments.

Rebalancing addresses these changes by restoring the intended allocation. Rather than letting market performance determine the portfolio’s risk profile, investors make deliberate adjustments to stay aligned with their established objectives.

Rebalancing Is About Risk Management, Not Market Prediction

One of the most important distinctions in portfolio management is the difference between disciplined rebalancing and attempting to predict future market movements. Rebalancing does not require an investor to determine which asset class will outperform next or whether a particular market has reached its peak. Instead, it establishes a structured process for maintaining an appropriate balance between investment opportunities and acceptable risk.

This distinction becomes particularly valuable when markets experience extended periods of strong performance. Investors may become reluctant to reduce exposure to successful investments, especially when recent returns have reinforced confidence in those positions. However, letting allocations drift indefinitely can gradually undermine the diversification intended to protect the portfolio from excessive concentration.

A disciplined rebalancing strategy evaluates whether current allocations remain within acceptable ranges. Adjustments may be triggered by significant deviations from target allocations, changes in personal financial circumstances, or scheduled portfolio reviews. The appropriate frequency depends on the investor’s objectives, portfolio complexity, transaction costs, and tax considerations.

Importantly, rebalancing does not guarantee higher returns or prevent investment losses. Its primary purpose is to maintain the portfolio’s intended risk characteristics and keep investment decisions consistent with a defined long-term strategy.

The Tax Consequences of Restoring Portfolio Balance

For Canadian investors, rebalancing can create tax considerations that should be evaluated before transactions are implemented. Selling appreciated investments in a non-registered account generally results in realized capital gains, which may increase taxable income for the year. As a result, restoring a portfolio’s intended allocation can involve a trade-off between maintaining investment discipline and managing immediate tax exposure.

Consider an investor whose equity allocation has increased beyond its intended range. Selling appreciated equity holdings may be the most direct way to restore balance, but those transactions could generate capital gains. If the investor also holds investments with unrealized losses, there may be opportunities to coordinate tax-loss selling with the rebalancing process.

Realized capital losses may generally be applied against capital gains, subject to applicable Canadian tax rules. This can potentially reduce the tax consequences of necessary portfolio adjustments while allowing the investor to improve diversification or reduce concentrated exposure.

However, tax considerations should not become the sole determinant of investment decisions. Avoiding a necessary adjustment simply to defer capital gains taxes may leave the portfolio exposed to risks that are inconsistent with the investor’s financial objectives. The appropriate approach balances the benefits of rebalancing against transaction costs, potential tax liabilities, and the consequences of maintaining an unintended allocation.

Rebalancing Does Not Always Require Selling Investments

Although rebalancing is frequently associated with selling appreciated assets, there are several ways to adjust portfolio allocations. In some circumstances, investors may be able to restore balance without immediately realizing taxable capital gains.

New contributions can be directed toward underweighted asset classes, gradually bringing the portfolio closer to its intended structure. Similarly, investors may allocate dividends, interest payments, and available cash to investments that require additional exposure. These approaches can reduce the need to sell appreciated holdings while maintaining progress toward the target allocation.

The location of investments across different account types can also influence rebalancing decisions. Adjustments within RRSPs, RRIFs, and TFSAs generally do not create immediate capital gains taxation within those accounts, although each account has distinct withdrawal rules and other considerations. This may provide opportunities to make certain allocation changes more efficiently than selling appreciated investments in non-registered accounts.

For investors with multiple accounts, rebalancing should therefore be evaluated at the total portfolio level rather than treating each account independently. An adjustment in one account may help restore the overall investment allocation without requiring unnecessary transactions elsewhere.

The objective is to achieve the appropriate investment structure through the most practical and tax-conscious combination of available options.

Why Year-End Is an Important Review Point

December 31 is not a mandatory portfolio rebalancing deadline. Nevertheless, the final months of the year provide a useful opportunity to evaluate whether investment allocations remain appropriate and whether potential adjustments should be coordinated with other financial decisions.

By November, investors generally have a clearer picture of how their portfolios have performed throughout the year. Significant gains and losses may be identifiable, changes in income or liquidity requirements may be better understood, and financial priorities for the following year may be coming into focus.

This information creates an opportunity to review portfolio positioning in the context of broader year-end planning. Investors may need to evaluate realized capital gains, identify potential tax-loss selling opportunities, prepare for upcoming withdrawals, or adjust allocations to reflect changes in retirement timelines and financial circumstances.

Waiting until the final weeks of December can compress the time available to assess these considerations. Transactions may require adjusted cost base calculations, tax analysis, settlement considerations, and coordination across multiple accounts. Starting the review earlier lets investors evaluate alternatives without making unnecessary changes simply because the calendar is approaching year-end.

When Your Financial Circumstances Change, Your Allocation May Need to Change Too

Not every portfolio adjustment is intended to restore an existing allocation. Sometimes the underlying investment strategy itself requires reconsideration because the investor’s circumstances have changed.

Approaching retirement, experiencing a significant change in income, receiving an inheritance, selling a business, or anticipating a substantial financial obligation can alter the relationship between investment growth, income generation, liquidity, and risk tolerance. A portfolio allocation that was appropriate several years ago may no longer reflect current financial priorities.

For example, an investor approaching retirement may need to focus more on cash flow and capital preservation than someone with several decades before withdrawals begin. Similarly, an investor who has accumulated a substantial position in a single company may need to consider concentration risk even if that holding has delivered strong historical performance.

These circumstances highlight why rebalancing should be connected to comprehensive financial planning. The purpose is not simply to maintain fixed percentages indefinitely, but to ensure that the investment structure continues to reflect the investor’s evolving objectives.

A year-end review provides an opportunity to determine whether the existing allocation remains appropriate before implementing transactions intended to restore it.

Consistency Is Built Through Disciplined Adjustments

Investment success is not determined exclusively by selecting securities that deliver strong returns. It also depends on maintaining an investment structure that can support financial objectives through changing market conditions.

Without a disciplined approach, portfolios can gradually become shaped by recent performance rather than intentional decisions. Successful holdings grow into increasingly large positions, diversification weakens, and the investor may unknowingly assume risks that were never part of the original plan.

Rebalancing provides a framework for addressing these changes. It creates a process to evaluate portfolio drift, manage concentration, and keep investment decisions aligned with long-term objectives. When coordinated with tax planning, the process can also help reduce unnecessary transaction costs and manage the tax consequences of necessary adjustments.

The value lies in consistency rather than prediction. Investors cannot control market movements, but they can establish a disciplined approach to managing how those movements influence their portfolios.

Keep Your Investment Strategy Working as Intended

As the year approaches its conclusion, reviewing your portfolio allocation is an important part of evaluating your overall financial position. Market performance may have changed your exposure to particular asset classes, sectors, or securities, while changes in your personal circumstances may have altered the level of risk appropriate for your objectives.

At Brook Wagman Private Family Wealth Management, we believe portfolio management should remain connected to long-term financial planning, risk management, and tax efficiency. Rebalancing is one part of that process, helping ensure investment decisions remain deliberate rather than dictated by market movements or year-end pressure.

The goal is not to make changes simply because December 31 is approaching. It is to determine whether your portfolio continues to support your financial objectives and, where appropriate, implement adjustments that preserve its intended structure.

Speak with the Brook Wagman Wealth Management & Planning team to review your portfolio allocation and identify whether any year-end adjustments may help strengthen your long-term investment strategy.

Contact Us Blog
First
Last
I'd like to receive marketing communications.

Disclaimer:
This newsletter has been prepared by Brook Wagman Private Wealth, and expresses the opinions of the author and not necessarily those of Raymond James Investment Counsel Ltd. (RJIC). Statistics, factual data and other information are from sources RJIC believes to be reliable, but their accuracy cannot be guaranteed. This newsletter is furnished on the basis and understanding that RJIC is to be under no liability whatsoever in respect thereof. It is for information purposes only and is not to be construed as an offer or solicitation for the sale or purchase of securities. RJIC and its officers, directors, employees and their families may from time to time invest in the securities discussed in this newsletter. This newsletter provides links to other Internet sites for the convenience of users. Raymond James Investment Counsel Ltd. is not responsible for the availability or content of these external sites, nor does Raymond James Investment Counsel Ltd. endorse, warrant or guarantee the products, services or information described or offered at these other Internet sites. Users cannot assume that the external sites will abide by the same Privacy Policy which Raymond James Investment Counsel Ltd. adheres. Commissions, trailing commissions, management fees and expenses all may be associated with mutual funds and the use of an asset allocation service. Please read the prospectus of the mutual funds in which investment may be made under the asset allocation service before investing. Mutual funds and other securities are not insured nor guaranteed; their values change frequently and past performance may not be repeated. Raymond James portfolio managers are not tax advisors, and we recommend that clients seek independent advice from a professional advisor on tax-related matters. This newsletter is intended for distribution only in those jurisdictions where RJIC is registered as a portfolio manager. Any distribution or dissemination of this newsletter in any other jurisdiction is strictly prohibited. Securities-related products and services are offered through Raymond James Investment Counsel Ltd. Insurance products and services are offered through Raymond James Financial Planning Ltd.