Skip to main content

Brook Wagman

Contact Us Today: +1 437 228 6291

What Happens When Portfolios Become Over concentrated

Why Successful Investments Can Quietly Change Your Risk

A portfolio can become riskier without a single new purchase. An investment performs well, grows faster than the other holdings, and gradually accounts for a larger share of the total. What began as a modest position becomes a significant driver of results. Because the change arrives alongside gains, it may attract little concern. This is one way portfolio concentration develops. An investor can end up depending heavily on one company, sector, or region without ever deciding to take that much risk.

Recognizing the change matters. An investment that helped build your wealth may eventually carry more responsibility for your financial future than you intended.

How Concentration Develops Gradually

Consider a hypothetical portfolio worth $500,000. One company represents $50,000, or 10% of the total. If that holding doubles while everything else remains unchanged, the portfolio grows to $550,000. The company now represents approximately 18% of the portfolio. The investor has made no additional purchase, yet the position’s influence has nearly doubled. Further gains could increase that influence again.

Concentration can also develop through repeated contributions to a favourite investment, accumulated employer shares, or an inherited holding. Each addition may seem manageable on its own. The useful comparison is between the portfolio you originally intended to hold and the portfolio you own today. A rising account balance does not tell you whether that allocation still suits your circumstances.

When One Holding Starts Driving the Outcome

A concentrated position gives one investment more power over the portfolio’s direction. That can support strong returns when the investment performs well. It also increases the consequences when performance deteriorates. Suppose one holding represents 30% of a portfolio and falls by 40%. If everything else remains unchanged, that decline reduces the overall portfolio’s value by 12%.

At a 5% weighting, the same decline would reduce the portfolio by 2%. These simplified examples exclude fees, taxes, and changes in other holdings. They illustrate how position size changes the effect of the same investment outcome. For someone approaching retirement or preparing for a major withdrawal, that difference may be consequential. The question becomes how much financial disruption one disappointing result could create.

More Investments Can Still Mean Similar Exposure

Concentration is not always visible as one oversized holding. It can exist across several investments that respond to similar conditions. An investor might own individual Canadian bank shares, a financial services fund, and a Canadian equity fund that also holds banks. The account contains different products, but their underlying exposures overlap. Adding another fund may therefore provide less diversification than expected.

Diversification involves spreading investments across asset classes, industries, and markets. Looking inside funds helps establish whether additional holdings broaden exposure or add to positions already represented elsewhere. A portfolio review should examine what the investments own and what affects their performance. Different names on a statement are only the first step in that assessment.

Your Financial Life Can Add Another Layer

Investment accounts are part of a larger financial picture. Consider someone who works for an energy company, receives shares through an employee plan, and holds additional energy investments personally. A downturn in that industry could pressure both employment income and investment values at the same time. A business owner may face a similar overlap when personal investments closely resemble the industry in which their business operates.

These situations deserve attention because financial pressures can arrive at the same time. An investor with reduced income may need savings just as related investments decline. Reviewing an RRSP, TFSA, and non-registered account together is useful. Extending that review to employment, business ownership, and upcoming spending needs helps show where several parts of your finances depend on similar outcomes.

Why Investors Hesitate to Restore Balance

Reducing a successful holding can feel uncomfortable. The investment may have rewarded patience for years, and selling part of it can feel like questioning a decision that worked. Investors may also worry about missing further gains or creating a tax bill. An inherited position can carry personal significance, making the decision harder. Those concerns deserve consideration, but they do not determine an appropriate position size.

A useful question is whether you would choose the same weighting if you were building the portfolio today. If the answer is no, identify what is keeping the existing allocation in place. That conversation can help separate confidence in an investment from comfort with how much money depends on it.

Restoring Balance Through a Planned Review

Start by confirming the allocation appropriate for your current goals. The right mix depends on your time horizon, financial objectives, and ability and willingness to accept risk. An older target may need updating if your circumstances have changed.

Then compare that target with your current holdings. Rebalancing may involve directing new contributions towards underrepresented investments or selling part of an oversized position. The approach should reflect how much adjustment is needed and the resources available. Implementation should account for the account type, potential tax consequences, transaction costs, and any restrictions on selling.

A gradual approach may be appropriate in some circumstances, while other situations may warrant faster adjustment. Any staged plan should acknowledge the concentration risk that remains during the transition.

What Diversification Can and Cannot Do

Diversification helps reduce dependence on individual investments and shared exposures. It does not prevent every loss. During widespread market stress, different holdings can decline together. A diversified portfolio may also trail a concentrated portfolio when the concentrated investments are performing particularly well. Maintaining balance involves accepting that trade-off.

No single position limit suits every investor. How much concentration someone can reasonably accept depends on their broader resources, objectives, and ability to absorb losses. Clear limits and review dates make those decisions easier to revisit. They create an opportunity to notice when investment success has changed the portfolio’s role in the plan.

Uncover What Is Hiding in Your Portfolio

In our comic book, The Scariest Mistakes Investors Make, and How to Avoid Them, an investor discovers that several holdings have more in common than expected. Hidden concentration becomes an important clue in the mystery. Your portfolio may deserve a similar review, especially if certain investments have grown substantially or several accounts have developed independently. The Brook Wagman Wealth Management & Planning team can help you examine your combined holdings, identify overlapping exposures, and consider adjustments that reflect your goals.

Read the comic book, then take a closer look at how much of your financial future depends on a handful of outcomes.

Speak With a Brook Wagman Wealth Management & Planning Team Member

The Brook Wagman Wealth Management & Planning team can help you look beyond individual holdings and consider how your investments support your broader financial life. Read the comic book, then take a closer look at the risks that may deserve attention before they become urgent.

Contact Us Blog
First
Last
I'd like to receive marketing communications.

Disclaimer:
This newsletter has been prepared by Brook Wagman Private Wealth, and expresses the opinions of the author and not necessarily those of Raymond James Investment Counsel Ltd. (RJIC). Statistics, factual data and other information are from sources RJIC believes to be reliable, but their accuracy cannot be guaranteed. This newsletter is furnished on the basis and understanding that RJIC is to be under no liability whatsoever in respect thereof. It is for information purposes only and is not to be construed as an offer or solicitation for the sale or purchase of securities. RJIC and its officers, directors, employees and their families may from time to time invest in the securities discussed in this newsletter. This newsletter provides links to other Internet sites for the convenience of users. Raymond James Investment Counsel Ltd. is not responsible for the availability or content of these external sites, nor does Raymond James Investment Counsel Ltd. endorse, warrant or guarantee the products, services or information described or offered at these other Internet sites. Users cannot assume that the external sites will abide by the same Privacy Policy which Raymond James Investment Counsel Ltd. adheres. Commissions, trailing commissions, management fees and expenses all may be associated with mutual funds and the use of an asset allocation service. Please read the prospectus of the mutual funds in which investment may be made under the asset allocation service before investing. Mutual funds and other securities are not insured nor guaranteed; their values change frequently and past performance may not be repeated. Raymond James portfolio managers are not tax advisors, and we recommend that clients seek independent advice from a professional advisor on tax-related matters. This newsletter is intended for distribution only in those jurisdictions where RJIC is registered as a portfolio manager. Any distribution or dissemination of this newsletter in any other jurisdiction is strictly prohibited. Securities-related products and services are offered through Raymond James Investment Counsel Ltd. Insurance products and services are offered through Raymond James Financial Planning Ltd.